Citywire Brussels Breakfast Briefing 2023

Welcome to Citywire Brussels Breakfast Briefing 2023! 

Following the success of our previous editions, we are proud to announce that Citywire will return to Brussels on Thursday 12 October 2023 to bring a group of leading fund selectors together again for our Brussels Breakfast Briefing.

Like so much of the financial world, the business of investment selection is changing faster than any of us can remember. Providing an energising morning, portfolio managers and investors will meet and interact, before we wrap up with a quickfire panel session. A sharp, clean new format that makes the very best use of everyone’s time. 

We very much look forward to welcoming you in Brussels!  

FABIAN FUCHS - 110x110
Fabian Fuchs
Senior Relationship Manager
PIETRO CECERE - JUNE 2017
Pietro Cecere
Head of European Research
Register

Sponsors

Selector Spotlight

Sustainable Investing with ESG Ratings Uncertainty

One of the biggest concerns related to ESG investing is inconsistency across ESG indexes and ratings, which makes it difficult for fund managers and investors to draw reliable insights and comparisons across firms. ESG ratings agencies have been criticized for a lack of standardization in what should be measured and how, as well as a lack of transparency concerning procedures used in the rankings process. Some opponents have called for ESG ratings to be overhauled or abandoned, while The Economist made the case that financial institutions should retreat from ESG and focus only on the environmental dimension, specifically carbon emissions.*

Furthermore, data is king and according to The Aggregate Confusion Project by MIT**, the correlation among prominent agencies’ ESG ratings is on average 0.54; by comparison, credit ratings from Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s are correlated at 0.92. This ambiguity around ESG ratings creates acute challenges for investors trying to achieve both financial and social return.

In a nutshell, ESG ratings vary widely so...

What is your biggest challenge when it comes to fund selection? Are there impacts on your fund & manager selection? How do you tackle the ESG ratings divergence? Do you have any ESG ratings provider (ESG corporate ratings and ESG fund ratings) you prefer? Why?

What’s the feedback from the fund managers you are invested/monitoring? What are you hearing from them? How do they tackle the ESG ratings divergence? How do they choose their ESG ratings provider and the ESG ratings? And, do they use more than one provider?

Should EU wide measures be implemented in order to limit the mis-selling and misuse of ESG ratings? In a nutshell, given their increasing importance, should ESG Ratings be regulated?

Investors use ESG ratings voraciously. This has a cost, with a recent ERM research study finding that 33 institutional investors spent an average of $487,000 per year on external ESG ratings, data, and consultants. Are ESG Ratings expensive?

Furthermore, companies trading on major exchanges in North America and Europe are far more likely to get properly rated than those trading elsewhere, especially those in emerging markets as well as SME, companies that have recently gone public, unlikely to be rated during their first year of listing, and not listed companies. Even within the ranks of stocks listed on major exchanges, companies with a higher market cap or free float get covered by more raters and have their ratings refreshed more frequently than other companies. Do ESG ratings narrow too much the investment universe?

But also, recent studies have highlighted investors’ criticism of ESG ratings including claims that they are not reliably predictive of future sustainability success and that they do not correlate with ESG risk management capability. What do you think? What would like to see happen in the future to ensure ESG ratings better serve companies, investors, and other stakeholders?

Lastly, what's your best advice to fund managers to tackle the ESG ratings divergence? And what's your best advice to your fund selector peers? 

In this new session, our guests will drill down on these burning questions, bringing our audience precious food for thought and sharing also best practices and learning lessons. 

Our panellists are:
- Jan Bronselaer, AG Insurance
- Evy Mercie, Nagelmackers

* ESG ratings: Don’t throw the baby out with the bath water, Beth Stackpole Feb 2023. MIT MANAGEMENT SLOAN SCHOOL
** MIT SLOAN SUSTAINABILITY INITIATIVE, The Aggregate Confusion Project

Brussels October 2023 - Panel

Workshops

12
October

08:00 - 08:55

Registration and Breakfast

08:55 - 09:00

Welcome

09:00 - 09:30

Presentation 1

09:35 - 10:05

Presentation 2

10:10 - 10:40

Presentation 3

10:45 - 11:15

Selector Spotlight

Register